Manslaughter

Speak with Our Legal Professionals

Why Our Services Stand Out

50 Years of Expertise

In all NSW / VIC courts

Accreditation

Specialists in Criminal Law

24/7 Available

Connect directly with us

Overview

Facing charges of manslaughter is an exceedingly serious matter, and it necessitates expert legal representation to secure the best possible outcome. Manslaughter is one of the most serious offenses stipulated in the Crimes Act 1900. It is categorized as any homicide that does not meet the threshold for murder. Essentially, if an action results in the death of another person, and the intent to kill or seriously injure the victim is absent, it is considered manslaughter. Unlike murder, manslaughter does not involve an intent to kill; rather, it often stems from factors such as excessive self-defense, provocation, or substantial impairment by an abnormality of mind. Notably, reasonable self-defense can lead to a verdict of not guilty. Additionally, a charge of criminally negligent manslaughter can be filed if an individual's actions result in another person's death, and it is determined that they were grossly negligent in failing to act. There are two types of manslaughter: voluntary manslaughter and involuntary manslaughter. 1. Voluntary Manslaughter Voluntary manslaughter occurs when an individual’s action or failure resulting in death is carried out with the intent to kill or cause severe harm, or with a reckless disregard for human life. The offender's culpability is mitigated due to circumstances such as excessive self-defense, provocation, or significant impairment resulting from a mental abnormality. Key elements of voluntary manslaughter often involve:

Intent to cause harm: The accused intends to harm the victim, but not necessarily to kill.
Provocation: The act is triggered by provocative actions or circumstances that would likely cause a reasonable person to lose self-contro2.

2. Involuntary Manslaughter Involuntary manslaughter, on the other hand, is characterized by the absence of intent to kill or cause serious harm. Instead, it results from reckless, negligent, or unlawful actions that lead to the unintentional death of another person. Involuntary manslaughter is often associated with acts or omissions that create a high risk of harm, even if the accused did not specifically intend to cause death. Key elements of involuntary manslaughter often include:

Gross negligence: The accused's actions or omissions constitute a significant breach of the duty of care expected of a reasonable person.
Unlawful conduct: The accused engages in an unlawful act that is not necessarily intended to cause death but results in a fatality. It is not required that you were aware that your act posed any danger. It is whether a reasonable person would have recognised that the act, given the circumstances, exposed others to the risk of serious injury.

Frequently Asked Questions

Click on the options below to learn the answers to frequently asked questions about Assault charges.

1. Identification: This defence asserts that someone other than the accused was responsible for causing the victim’s death.

2. Cause of Death: This defence argues that the actions of the accused were not the direct cause of the victim’s death.

3. Self-Defence: The law recognizes an individual’s right to act in self-defence when faced with a physical attack or a credible threat. However, this defence hinges on the requirement that the response must be reasonable given the circumstances. Self-defence can also extend to the defence of another person.

4. Duress: Duress comes into play when a person’s actions are performed under the threat of death or serious injury, and those threats would likely compel a person of ordinary courage to yield. It provides a legal defence for individuals who acted under significant coercion.

5. Necessity: The common law defence of necessity operates when circumstances, whether they be natural or human threats, exert pressure on the accused. These circumstances induce the accused to break the law to prevent even more dire consequences. There is some overlap between the defence of necessity and the defence of duress, as both involve external pressures compelling unlawful actions.

If you acknowledge that you have committed the offence of manslaughter, and the police can prove their case, it is often advisable to plead guilty. Doing so can have several potential benefits:

1. Sentence Discount: Pleading guilty typically results in a reduced sentence compared to what you might receive if you were found guilty after a trial. This discount reflects your willingness to take responsibility for your actions and saves the court time and resources.

2. Demonstrating Remorse and Contrition: A guilty plea is an expression of remorse and contrition, which can be viewed positively by the court. It indicates that you recognize the gravity of your actions and are willing to face the consequences.

3. Negotiation Opportunities: Experienced solicitors can sometimes negotiate with prosecutors to have you plead guilty to lesser facts or even a less serious charge. This can potentially lead to a more favorable outcome in terms of sentencing

However, it’s important to note that the decision to plead guilty should not be taken lightly. Seek advice from one of our experienced criminal defence lawyers who will thoroughly assess your case, and determine the best course of action for you. Your legal representative can guide you through the process and ensure that your rights are protected throughout the proceedings.

In NSW, there are two additional murder charges.

1. Assault Causing Death under s 25A of the Crimes Act 1900 (NSW) which was introduced in 2013 to combat “one-punch” deaths.

2. Drug Supply Causing Death under s 25C of the Crimes Act 1900 (NSW)